Design of a floor for lateral loads

How do Skylark floors deal with lateral loads?

Skylark floors transfer lateral loads such as wind and earthquakes into the shear walls. It is important to make sure that the floor (also called diaphragm) has enough capacity to transfer such loads. If the load is parallel to the longitudinal axis of the beams, this means checking the floor bow ties for tension and shear.

A design example according to the Eurocodes is shown below.

Worked example

A Skylark floor made by 6 XS beams, 12 L beams and 2 end beams is subjected to lateral wind pressure equal to \(q\) = 4kN/m (UltimateLimit State). Verify that the diaphragm satisfies the design criteria according to the Eurocodes.

Geometry

The geometry of the diaphragm is shown in the figure below. The  floor is made up of 18 beams and two end beams, for a total footprint of 6.0 m x 11.4 m. Beams are connected together by using bow ties, which are spaced according to the figure below. The 3D model can be dowloaded from here.

Geometry of the diaphragm.

The elements are made of \(w=18 mm\) thick plywood sheets. Material properties are reported in the table below.

Parameter Value Unit Description
E 8000 MPa Elastic modulus
G 350 MPa Shear modulus
\(f_{c,0}\) 20 MPa Compressive strength (main direction)
\(f_{t,0}\) 12 MPa Tensile strength (main direction)
\(f_{c,90}\) 10 MPa Compressive strength (weak direction)
\(f_{t,90}\) 6 MPa Tensile strength (weak direction)
\(f_s\) 3.5 MPa Shear strength

Actions on the diaphragm

Assuming a simply supported static scheme, the diaphragm is subjected to bending moment and shear. Therefore, bow ties are subjected to both shear and tensile forces.

An illustration of Skylark floor beams subjected to shear and tension, highlighting the rows of connectors studied.

Three rows of bow ties are considered to find out the worst case scenario. The values of shear (V) and bending moment (M) are calculated based on the bow tie distance z from the support:

\[M(z)=-\frac{qz^2}{2}+\frac{qLz}{2}\]

\[T(z)=\frac{qL}{2}-qz\]

Given L=11.4 m and q=4kN/m, it follows:

Row z (m) V (kN) M(kNm)
1 0.316 21.6 7.0
2 3.916 7.2 58.9
3 5.718 0.0 65.4

Capacity of the Diaphragm

Capacity of the bow tie

The tensile capacity of one bow tie \(T\) is calculated as the minimum force between the tension failure \(T_t\) and the compression/shear failure \(T_c\).

Drawings of 2 bowie connectors, using arrows to illustrate the structural failure mechanisms.
Bow tie failure mechanisms

\(T_t\) can be calculated as:

\(T_t=\underbrace{f_{t,0} A_t}_{12\cdot 55.7 \cdot18}=12\ kN
\)

The calculation of \(T_c\) requires the following iterative process:

1. Select an arbitrary \(T_c\), for example 1 kN.

2. Calculate the bow tie slip \(s=\frac{F_2}{k_t}\) where \(k_t\) is the bow tie stiffness in tension.

3. Calculate the contact zone between the bow tie and the panel by considering the bow tie slip.

4. Decompose \(T_c\) into \(T_{c,comp}\) (compression force) and \(T_{c,shear}\) (shear) on the contact zone.

5. Calculate the compression stress \(\sigma_C\) and \(\tau_S\) by considering the contact area.

6. Check if  the element has failed according to \(\frac{\sigma_c}{f_{c,d}}+\frac{\tau_s}{f_s}=1\). If not, increase \(T_c\) until failure.

The iterative calculations are reported in the spreadsheet here. The "goal seek" function was used.

This leads to \(T=5.2 kN\). By considering \(k_{mod}=1.1\) (load duration factor for instantaneous events), this leads to \(T=5.7 kN\).

The shear capacity \(S\) of the bow tie is equal to:


\(S=\underbrace{A_s}_{55.7 \cdot 18}\overbrace{f_s}^{3.5}=3.5\ kN
\)

By considering \(k_{mod}=1.1\) (load duration factor for instantaneous events), this leads to \(S=3.85 kN\).

Shear capacity of the diaphragm

The shear capacity \(V_{rd}\) of the diaphragm can be calculated as:

\(V_{rd}=nS\)

where \(n\) is the number of bow ties and \(S\) is the shear capacity of the bow tie.

It follows that:

\[V_{rd,1}=V_{rd,2}=\frac{\overbrace{n}^{12}\overbrace{S}^{3.85}}{\underbrace{\gamma}_{1.2}}=38.5\ kN\]

\[V_{rd,3}=\frac{\overbrace{n}^{18}\overbrace{S}^{3.85}}{\underbrace{\gamma}_{1.2}}=57.8\ kN\]

Moment capacity of the diaphragm

The moment capacity \(M_{rd}\) of the diaphragm can be calculated as:

\[M_{rd}=\frac{\sum_i^{n}d_iT_i}{\gamma}\]

where \(n\) is the number of bow ties, \(T_i\) is the tensile capacity of the \(i^{th}\) bow tie, \(d_i\) is the distance of the \(i^{th}\) bow tie from the pivoting point and \(\gamma\) is the safety factor.

The easiest way is to build a spreadsheet similar to this one. This leads to:

i [-] d_i [mm] d_i/d_n T [kN] T_i*d_i (kNm)
1 203 0.06 0.3 0.07
2 398 0.12 0.7 0.27
3 803 0.24 1.3 1.08
4 998 0.29 1.7 1.67
5 1403 0.41 2.4 3.30
6 1598 0.47 2.7 4.28
7 2003 0.59 3.4 6.73
8 2198 0.65 3.7 8.10
9 2603 0.77 4.4 11.37
10 2798 0.82 4.7 13.13
11 3203 0.94 5.4 17.21
12 3398 1.00 5.7 19.37
86.58

Screenshot of floor modelled to check tension test calculations.

This leads to:

\[M_{rd,1}=M_{rd,2}=\frac{\sum_i^{12}\overbrace{d_iT_i}^{86.58}}{\underbrace{\gamma}_{1.2}}=72.2\ kNm\]

i [-] d_i [mm] d_i/d_n T [kN] T_i*d_i (kNm)
1 203 0.04 0.2 0.05
2 398 0.08 0.4 0.17
3 803 0.15 0.9 0.71
4 998 0.19 1.1 1.09
5 1403 0.27 1.5 2.16
6 1598 0.31 1.8 2.80
7 2003 0.39 2.2 4.40
8 2198 0.42 2.4 5.30
9 2603 0.50 2.9 7.43
10 2798 0.54 3.1 8.58
11 3203 0.62 3.5 11.25
12 3398 0.65 3.7 12.66
13 3803 0.73 4.2 15.86
14 3998 0.77 4.4 17.53
15 4403 0.85 4.8 21.26
16 4598 0.88 5.0 23.18
17 5003 0.96 5.5 27.45
18 5198 1.00 5.7 29.63
191.51

This leads to:

\[M_{rd,1}=M_{rd,2}=\frac{\sum_i^{12}\overbrace{d_iT_i}^{86.5

This leads to:

\[M_{rd,3}=\frac{\sum_i^{18}\overbrace{d_iT_i}^{191.5}}{\underbrace{\gamma}_{1.2}}=159.6\ kNm\]

Capacity check

It is verified that:

\[\frac{\overbrace{V_{sd,1}}^{21.6}}{\underbrace{V_{rd,1}}_{38.5}}+\frac{\overbrace{M_{sd,1}}^{7}}{\underbrace{M_{rd,1}}_{72.2}}=0.67\le1\ \checkmark\]

\[\frac{\overbrace{V_{sd,2}}^{7.2}}{\underbrace{V_{rd,2}}_{38.5}}+\frac{\overbrace{M_{sd,2}}^{58.9}}{\underbrace{M_{rd,2}}_{72.2}}=1.0\le1\ \checkmark\]

\[\frac{\overbrace{V_{sd,3}}^{0}}{\underbrace{V_{rd,3}}_{38.5}}+\frac{\overbrace{M_{sd,3}}^{65.4}}{\underbrace{M_{rd,3}}_{191.5}}=0.34\le1\ \checkmark\]

Finite element model

An elastic finite element model was developed in Karamba3D to check the results. The diaphragm was modelled by using a shell element with thickness equal to 18 mm. Bow ties were modelled with a single elastic spring having \(k_t=\ 1.5\ kN/mm\) and \(k_s=3\ kN/mm\). The model is available here for download.

To check the calculation of \(M_{rd}\), the diaphragm is loaded by a distributed wind load \(q_{rd}\) proportional to the moment capacity.

case 1

Considering \(q_{rd,2}\):

\(q_{rd,2}=\frac{\overbrace{M_{rd,2}}^{86.6}}{\underbrace{M_{sd,2}}_{58.9}}\cdot \overbrace{q_{sd}}^{4}=5.9\ kN/m\)

leads to a tensile force equal to 5.5 kN in the \(12^{th}\) bow tie in row 2. Results are consistent with the analytical model.

Screenshot of floor modelled to check tension test calculations.

case 2

Considering \(q_{rd,3}\):

\[q_{rd,3}=\frac{\overbrace{M_{rd,2}}^{191.5}}{\underbrace{M_{sd,2}}_{65.4}}\cdot \overbrace{q_{sd}}^{4}=11.7\ kN/m\]

leads to a tensile force equal to 5.5 kN in the \(18^{th}\) bow tie in row 3. Results are consistent with the analytical model.

Screenshot of floor modelled to check tension test calculations.

Please do

A tick mark. Means yes, you can do this.

Use it

Most WikiHouse files and information are licensed under a Creative Commons–Sharealike licence, so you are free to use, distribute or modify them, including commercially.

A tick mark. Means yes, you can do this.

Check it

All WikiHouse information is shared 'as is', without warranties or guarantees of any kind. You are responsible for checking it and using it in a safe and responsible way, for example, getting it checked by a structural engineer.

A tick mark. Means yes, you can do this.

Comply with regulations

You are responsible for making sure your project complies with all relevant local regulations, including planning, building codes and health & safety legislation. If in doubt, seek professional advice.

A tick mark. Means yes, you can do this.

Re-share your improvements

If you make any improvements to the system, you must publish your files under the same type of open licence. However, you do not need to publish the plans and specifications for individual projects unless you wish to.

Please do not

A cross. Means no, you can't do this.

Call yourself WikiHouse

Do not call your company, organisation or any marketed product or service 'WikiHouse'. However, you may use the term WikiHouse to talk about the system, and you may describe your project, product, service or organisation as, for example, "using WikiHouse", "based on WikiHouse", "contributing to WikiHouse", or similar.

A cross. Means no, you can't do this.

Remove notices

Do not remove any licence notices from files if you are re-sharing them.

A cross. Means no, you can't do this.

Claim to be endorsed

Do not give the impression that you are endorsed by, or affiliated with WikiHouse or Open Systems Lab (unless you are, by written agreement), and do not claim to represent the WikiHouse project or community as a whole.